in
History
—
Tragedy at May Island: The Royal Navy's Secret WWI Submarine Disaster
In 1918, a Royal Navy exercise off Scotland's May Island turned into a self-inflicted disaster. A series of collisions among friendly submarines in foggy conditions resulted in two subs sunk, several damaged, and over 100 lives lost without enemy contact.
A Collision Course with History
In the grand theater of the First World War, naval conflict conjures images of dreadnoughts clashing in the North Sea or German U-boats stalking convoys in the Atlantic. Yet, one of the Royal Navy's most devastating submarine incidents involved no enemy action whatsoever. On the cold, dark night of January 31, 1918, a series of catastrophic errors and ill-fated coincidences led to a friendly-fire disaster in the Firth of Forth, Scotland. Dubbed the "Battle of May Island," it was a conflict where the only adversary was a combination of flawed technology, poor visibility, and human error. For decades, the incident was shrouded in official secrecy, a painful footnote in naval history that cost the lives of over 100 sailors.
The "Kalamity" Class Submarine
At the heart of the tragedy were the K-class submarines, a unique and ambitious design for their time. Unlike conventional submarines designed for slow, stealthy patrols, the K-class was engineered for speed. Powered by steam turbines on the surface, they could achieve over 24 knots, allowing them to keep pace with the Grand Fleet's battleships and act as an advance screen. However, this innovation came at a steep price. They were notoriously complex, with large funnels that had to be sealed before diving—a process that could take several minutes. They handled poorly when submerged and were plagued by mechanical issues, earning them the grim moniker "Kalamity class" among their crews. The design, while forward-thinking, introduced a host of new dangers into an already perilous service.
A Night of Fog and Errors
The stage for the disaster was Operation EC1, a large-scale fleet exercise originating from Rosyth. The force included battleships, battlecruisers, destroyers, and two flotillas of K-class submarines. As the fleet steamed out into the North Sea under the cover of darkness, two critical conditions prevailed: the ships were running without full navigation lights to simulate wartime conditions, and strict radio silence was in effect to prevent enemy detection. Shortly after departure, the lead vessel of the 13th Flotilla, K14, suffered a jammed rudder, forcing it to swerve out of line. In the confusion, the following submarine, K22, collided with it. Both submarines were damaged and stopped in the water, directly in the path of the oncoming fleet. Due to radio silence, the flotilla commander and the rest of the capital ships were completely unaware of the accident that had occurred behind them.
A Cascade of Collisions
What followed was a chain reaction of horrors. The main battle fleet, having completed its turn as part of the exercise, was now steaming back towards the two stricken submarines. The battlecruiser HMS Inflexible struck K22 a glancing blow, compounding the damage. As destroyers and cruisers swerved to avoid the chaos, the situation became increasingly frantic. The 12th Submarine Flotilla, steaming behind the larger ships, sailed directly into the disaster zone. Its lead cruiser, HMS Fearless, ploughed into K17, sinking it in under eight minutes. While other vessels stopped to rescue survivors from K17, the rest of the flotilla descended into confusion. In the darkness, K6 sliced into K4, almost cutting it in half. As K4 foundered, it was struck again by K7. HMS K4 sank with all 56 hands on board. In less than 75 minutes, a routine exercise had devolved into a maritime catastrophe, resulting in two submarines sunk, four others severely damaged, and 104 men killed. Not a single enemy shell had been fired.
A Battle in Name Only
The Admiralty immediately classified the incident, swearing all survivors to secrecy to avoid damaging wartime morale. The full story of the "Battle of May Island" would not be revealed to the public until many years later. The name itself is a source of tragic irony, a point often raised by historians and naval enthusiasts. As one researcher noted:
The term "Battle" seems to be contemporary, despite the absence of an enemy. It has a tragic irony.
This wasn't a battle against a foreign power but a devastating struggle against the elements, mechanical failure, and the fog of war itself. It stands as a stark reminder that even in the absence of an enemy, the sea and the machinery of war remain unforgiving forces. The disaster highlighted the inherent flaws of the K-class design and led to crucial re-evaluations of naval communication and operational procedures, lessons paid for with the lives of dedicated sailors on a dark night off the Scottish coast.