in
Science & Nature
—
A Tale of a Giant and Two Pebbles: The Astonishing Size Difference Between Earth's Moon and Mars'
Earth's Moon is a behemoth at over 2,100 miles wide, likely formed from a planetary collision. In stark contrast, Mars' moons, Phobos and Deimos, are tiny, potato-shaped captured asteroids measuring just 14 and 7.5 miles across, with dramatically different cosmic destinies.
When we gaze up at the night sky, our Moon, Luna, dominates the view. It’s a familiar, reassuring presence, a colossal sphere over 2,100 miles in diameter that feels like an intrinsic part of our world. It’s so significant that we simply call it “the Moon.” But this normalcy is deceiving. Compared to the moons of our planetary neighbor, Mars, our companion is an absolute giant, and its story is far more dramatic.
A Tale of Two Systems
Let's talk scale. If our Moon were a basketball, Mars' two moons, Phobos and Deimos, would be mere peas. Phobos, the larger of the two, has a diameter of about 14 miles. Deimos is even smaller, at a scant 7.5 miles across. They aren't spheres, but lumpy, potato-shaped rocks. Their gravity is too weak to crush them into the round shape we associate with a moon. They are cosmic debris, celestial footnotes compared to the planetary-scale body orbiting Earth.
Violent Births and Timid Adoptions
The origins of these moons couldn't be more different. The leading theory for our Moon's creation is the Giant-Impact Hypothesis. This model suggests that early in our solar system's history, a Mars-sized protoplanet named Theia slammed into Earth. The resulting explosion of molten rock and debris was flung into orbit, eventually coalescing to form the massive Moon we have today. It was born from a cataclysm that reshaped our own world.
The story of Phobos and Deimos is likely far less dramatic. Most scientists believe they are captured asteroids, wanderers from the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter that strayed too close and were ensnared by Martian gravity. Their composition closely matches that of carbonaceous asteroids found in the outer belt. While some debate remains—their stable, circular orbits are unusual for captured objects—their tiny size and irregular shapes strongly suggest they were adopted, not born, by Mars.
A Matter of Perspective
Despite being a tiny speck, Phobos holds a surprise. Because it orbits incredibly close to Mars—just 3,700 miles above the surface—it appears quite large in the Martian sky. From the perspective of an observer on Mars, Phobos would look about one-third as large as our own full Moon appears to us. Deimos, orbiting much farther out, would look like little more than a very bright star, similar to how we see Venus from Earth.
Divergent Destinies
The futures of these moons are as divergent as their pasts. Our Moon is slowly drifting away from Earth, at a rate of about 1.5 inches per year. Mars' moons, however, are on very different paths. Deimos is slowly moving away, destined to eventually escape Mars' orbit entirely. Phobos, on the other hand, is doomed.
Tidal forces are pulling Phobos closer to Mars at a rate of about 6 feet (1.8 meters) every hundred years.
Within the next 50 million years, it will either be torn apart by the planet's gravity, forming a faint ring around Mars, or it will crash spectacularly into the Martian surface. This inexorable death spiral highlights the dynamic and often violent nature of celestial mechanics. While our giant Moon stabilizes our planet's tilt and tides, Mars' tiny companions are ephemeral, serving as a reminder that nothing in the cosmos is permanent.
Ultimately, the comparison reveals just how special the Earth-Moon system is. We don't just have a moon; we have a planetary partner, a colossal relic of our world's violent past that stands in stark contrast to the captured pebbles circling our neighbor.