in
Society & Social Issues
—
Buried Fortune, Poisoned Wells? The Story of Virginia's Forbidden Uranium
Beneath Virginia's rolling hills lies the largest U.S. uranium deposit, a potential energy goldmine. However, a decades-long state ban, upheld by the Supreme Court, keeps it buried due to fears of catastrophic groundwater contamination in the state's wet climate.
Deep beneath the pastoral landscape of Pittsylvania County, Virginia, lies a geological jackpot: the Coles Hill deposit, the largest known reserve of uranium in the United States. Estimated to be worth billions of dollars, this immense resource could theoretically power every home in the nation for two years. Yet, for over four decades, it has remained untouched, locked away by a state moratorium born from profound environmental fears. This is the story of a buried fortune and the battle to keep it that way.
A Discovery and a Dilemma
In the late 1970s, geologists discovered the massive deposit, containing an estimated 119 million pounds of uranium. For a region grappling with the decline of its traditional tobacco and textile industries, the discovery promised an economic renaissance, bringing high-paying jobs and a massive tax base. The company Virginia Uranium, Inc., owned by the family who has farmed the land for generations, championed the project as a path to local prosperity and American energy independence.
However, the geology that created the deposit also created a critical problem: its location. Unlike the arid deserts of the American West where most U.S. uranium mining has historically occurred, Coles Hill is situated in a temperate, wet climate. Virginia is prone to heavy rainfall and hurricanes, raising a terrifying question: what would happen if a major storm breached the containment facilities holding uranium tailings—the radioactive, toxic waste left after milling?
The Fear of Tainted Water
The primary concern has always been the potential for catastrophic groundwater and surface water contamination. The Coles Hill deposit sits at the headwaters of the Roanoke River Basin, a watershed that provides drinking water to hundreds of thousands of people, including the major coastal city of Virginia Beach. Opponents of the mine argued that a single leak or containment failure could send a toxic plume of radioactive material downstream, poisoning water supplies for generations.
These fears led Virginia to enact a statewide moratorium on uranium mining in 1982. A comprehensive 2012 study by the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) validated many of these concerns. While the report did not recommend for or against lifting the ban, it highlighted the immense challenges. The NAS panel noted that Virginia had no experience or existing regulatory framework for ensuring the safety of modern uranium mining, especially given its unique climate.
According to the National Academy of Sciences, if Virginia were to lift its moratorium, it would be faced with the challenge of developing a program of laws and regulations that would be sufficient to address the health and environmental effects of uranium mining, milling, and reclamation, which would be subject to a great deal of uncertainty.
From the Statehouse to the Supreme Court
The battle over Coles Hill raged for years, culminating in a legal showdown that reached the highest court in the land. Virginia Uranium, Inc. argued that the state's ban infringed on the federal government's exclusive authority to regulate nuclear safety, as established by the Atomic Energy Act. They contended that because the federal government oversees the milling and disposal of uranium, the state couldn't preemptively ban the mining that precedes it.
In 2019, the U.S. Supreme Court settled the matter in the case of Virginia Uranium, Inc. v. Warren. In a 6-3 decision, the Court sided with the Commonwealth of Virginia, affirming that states retain the right to regulate mining activities on private land for reasons of conventional environmental and public health protection, an authority separate from the federal government's oversight of nuclear safety. The ruling effectively solidified the state's four-decade-old ban.
A Sleeping Giant
Today, the uranium at Coles Hill remains in the ground, a silent testament to a complex modern dilemma. The case represents a powerful clash between economic opportunity, energy policy, and the paramount importance of environmental stewardship. While proponents see a wasted resource vital for nuclear power's role in a clean energy future, opponents see a disaster averted. For now, Virginia has chosen to prioritize the safety of its water over the wealth beneath its soil, leaving the nation's largest uranium deposit as a sleeping giant.