in
Society & Social Issues
—
Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo... Torture: The Disturbing Case of Oklahoma Guards and the 'Baby Shark' Song
In 2019, Oklahoma County jail guards faced criminal charges and a federal lawsuit after forcing inmates to listen to "Baby Shark" on a loud loop for hours while handcuffed. The lawsuit described the practice as a form of psychological torture, sparking a debate on cruel and unusual punishment.
It’s the children's song that became an inescapable global phenomenon. With its simple tune and repetitive lyrics, "Baby Shark" has entertained millions of toddlers and driven countless parents to the brink of insanity. But in a bizarre and disturbing case out of Oklahoma, that same catchy song was allegedly weaponized, turning a playroom anthem into a tool of torture.
What Happened in the Oklahoma County Jail?
Between November and December 2019, at least four inmates at the Oklahoma County Detention Center were subjected to a cruel form of discipline. According to prosecutors and a subsequent federal lawsuit, two now-former detention officers, Christian Miles and Gregory Butler Jr., would remove inmates from their cells in the middle of the night. The inmates were taken to an empty attorney visitation room, handcuffed to a wall in a standing position, and forced to listen to "Baby Shark" on a continuous loop at a high volume for hours.
The actions were not isolated incidents. Their supervisor, former Lt. Christopher Hendershott, was accused of being aware of the practice and doing nothing to stop it. This wasn't a prank gone wrong; investigators described it as a systematic and coordinated punishment.
"Tantamount to Torture" - The Lawsuit
While the officers faced misdemeanor criminal charges, the case gained national attention when the inmates filed a federal civil rights lawsuit. The suit alleged that the prolonged, loud, and repetitive music, combined with being forced to stand handcuffed for hours, was a form of psychological torture designed to inflict severe emotional and mental distress. David Prater, the Oklahoma County District Attorney, was blunt in his assessment, stating the practice was "unfortunate" and that he "would have preferred filing a felony sheet."
Cameron Spradling, the attorney for the inmates, argued the method was a known tool for breaking down prisoners.
"The Baby Shark song was used as an instrument to cause them even more suffering than the corporal punishment of being handcuffed and forced to stand... It's something that they are using as a device to literally physically and mentally torture these individuals."
A Joke or a Human Rights Violation?
On the surface, the story might sound absurd, almost like a dark comedy sketch. This initial reaction, common in online discussions, often gives way to a more serious question: When does punishment cross the line into torture? While a child's song seems trivial, its use in this context aligns with established psychological tactics. The United Nations has recognized that sensory overload—including exposure to continuous loud music—can constitute torture.
Historically, the U.S. military and intelligence agencies have used music by artists like Metallica, Eminem, and even Barney the Dinosaur during interrogations at facilities like Guantanamo Bay to disorient and break the will of detainees. The method leverages sleep deprivation and psychological stress. The Oklahoma case, while involving a far more whimsical soundtrack, operates on the same disturbing principle: weaponizing sound to inflict suffering.
Justice and a Tragic Update
The criminal case against the guards concluded with Miles and Butler pleading no contest to misdemeanor charges and receiving two years of probation. The charges against their supervisor, Hendershott, were dismissed. However, the federal civil rights lawsuit continued.
The story took a tragic turn in September 2022. One of the plaintiffs, John Basco, was found dead in his cell at the same Oklahoma County jail where the "Baby Shark" incidents occurred. He was 48. While the cause of death was investigated, his passing cast a somber shadow over the case, highlighting the grim realities faced by individuals within the troubled facility.
The "Baby Shark" torture case serves as a bizarre yet potent reminder of the ongoing debate surrounding prison reform and the definition of humane treatment. It shows how easily the line between discipline and abuse can be blurred, and how even the most innocent-seeming things can be twisted into instruments of cruelty.