in
Food & Lifestyle
—
Forbidden Feast: President Taft's Old-School Soup Is Now Illegal
President Taft's favorite dish was green sea turtle soup, a Gilded Age delicacy. Today, this specific soup is illegal in the U.S. because the turtle is protected under the Endangered Species Act, turning a presidential feast into a powerful lesson in conservation.
Imagine a lavish White House dinner during the Gilded Age. The guest of honor is President William Howard Taft, a man renowned for his discerning palate and hearty appetite. On the menu is his absolute favorite dish: a rich, savory, and complex turtle soup. A century ago, this was the height of culinary luxury. Today, serving that same recipe could land a chef in serious legal trouble.
A Taste of Presidential Luxury
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, green turtle soup was the ultimate status symbol. It was a fixture at royal banquets and high-society dinners, celebrated for its unique flavor, often described as a mix between veal and beef, with a gelatinous texture that was highly prized. For President Taft, it was more than just a meal; it was an obsession. His fondness for the dish was so great that he employed a specific chef just to master it.
So fond was the 27th President of this particular delicacy that he had his personal chef, Lonzo Ricks, travel with him to prepare it wherever he went.
This soup wasn't just food; it was a demonstration of power and wealth. Sourcing the key ingredient—the green sea turtle—was a costly and difficult endeavor, making each bowl a symbol of extravagance that was perfectly suited for the presidential table.
From Delicacy to Endangered
The secret to the soup's acclaimed flavor was its main ingredient, the green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas). Unfortunately, its popularity was its downfall. For centuries, these turtles were hunted relentlessly for their meat, eggs, and shells. The demand for turtle soup, particularly in America and Europe, drove a global trade that decimated their populations. The very dish that graced President Taft's table was pushing its star ingredient toward extinction.
The Law Steps In
The tide began to turn in the latter half of the 20th century with the rise of the modern conservation movement. Recognizing the catastrophic decline of many species, the United States passed the Endangered Species Act (ESA) in 1973. This landmark legislation provided a framework for protecting and recovering imperiled species and the ecosystems upon which they depend. The green sea turtle was among the first animals to receive protection under the act. With the stroke of a pen, it became illegal to hunt, capture, harm, or sell green sea turtles in the United States. President Taft's favorite soup was officially off the menu—permanently.
The Soup That Lives On (Sort Of)
While you can no longer legally dine on the authentic Gilded Age recipe, the tradition of turtle soup hasn't vanished entirely. If you see it on a menu today, especially in places like New Orleans, it's a different dish altogether. Modern turtle soup is typically made from non-endangered species, most commonly the common snapping turtle, which can be legally farmed or harvested. This Creole version is a beloved local specialty, but it is a distinct culinary creation from the one Taft enjoyed. Additionally, there has long been a tradition of "mock turtle soup," a recipe historically made from calf's head to mimic the texture of the original, proving that chefs have been creating workarounds for this elusive dish for centuries.
The story of Taft's favorite soup is more than a historical curiosity. It's a powerful reminder of how our culinary tastes can have a profound impact on the natural world, and how conservation laws can reshape our menus forever. The dish has been transformed from a presidential feast into a forbidden legacy.