in
Science & Nature
—
The Crows Have Eyes: How a University Study Revealed Crows Remember and Judge Human Faces
University of Washington researchers found that crows not only remember the faces of humans who have wronged them but also teach their friends and offspring to hold the same grudge. This remarkable study reveals the complex social intelligence and long-term memory of these common urban birds.
Have you ever walked past a crow and felt like you were being watched, or even judged? It might not be your imagination. These intelligent, black-feathered birds are not only watching us, but they’re also remembering us. And as researchers at the University of Washington discovered, they hold a grudge for a very, very long time.
The Experiment of the Dangerous Face
In the mid-2000s, Professor John Marzluff and his team embarked on a fascinating, and slightly menacing, field experiment on the University of Washington campus. The goal was to understand if wild crows could recognize individual human faces. To do this, they needed to give the crows a reason to remember someone. The researchers wore a specific, distinctive mask—often described as a primitive or "caveman" mask—while they trapped, banded, and then safely released seven American crows. This brief, stressful encounter was designed to be memorable, marking the wearer of that specific mask as a threat.
To ensure their results were valid, the team also had a control group. Other researchers would walk through the same areas wearing a different, "neutral" mask. In a now-famous detail, one of the neutral masks used was of former U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney.
A Grudge is Born
The results were immediate and dramatic. Researchers could walk around the campus unbothered without a mask. But the moment one of them put on the "dangerous" caveman mask, the campus crows erupted. The original seven banded crows began to "scold" the masked individual with harsh, repeated calls. They would follow the person, dive-bombing them from above and creating a cacophony of angry squawks. This wasn't a random act of aggression; it was a targeted response to a specific face they had learned to associate with danger.
What started with a handful of birds quickly escalated. On one occasion, a researcher wearing the mask was mobbed by a flock of 47 crows, all joining in the alarm. The researchers wearing the neutral Cheney mask? They were completely ignored. The birds had successfully distinguished a friend from a foe.
Spreading the Word: Crow Culture in Action
Perhaps the most groundbreaking discovery of the study wasn't just that crows could remember a face, but that they could share that information. Crows that had never been trapped or banded began to join in the harassment of the "dangerous" mask-wearer. How? They learned by watching the reactions of the original crows. This is a profound example of social learning, a form of cultural transmission previously thought to be rare outside of humans and other primates.
"The initial crows that were trapped were the ones that learned the mask was dangerous. They would scold the person wearing the mask. Their fledglings, which were not trapped, learned from their parents. Other crows in the flock learned from the scolding crows. The behavior spread from bird to bird."
Even more remarkably, the grudge was passed down through generations. Years later, new generations of crows on campus, who had never seen the original trapping event, continued to harass anyone wearing the caveman mask. The "story" of the dangerous face had become part of the local crow culture.
A Look Inside the Crow's Brain
To understand what was happening on a neurological level, Marzluff's team took their research a step further. They humanely captured some of the crows—both those who had been exposed to the dangerous mask and those who had not—and showed them the masks while scanning their brains using fMRI technology. When the experienced crows saw the "dangerous" face, their brains showed activity in regions analogous to the human amygdala, an area involved in processing fear and emotional memories. Their brain activity mirrored what you might see in a human remembering a traumatic event. It was scientific proof of a deeply held, emotionally charged memory.
The University of Washington crow study revealed a stunning level of cognitive complexity. These birds are not just part of our urban backdrop; they are intelligent individuals living in complex social networks. They recognize our faces, remember our actions, form opinions about us, and share that information with their friends and family for years. So the next time you see a crow, give it a respectful nod. It’s better to be remembered as a neutral party—or better yet, a friend who offers an unsalted peanut—than as the person wearing the dangerous mask.