in
Music
—
The Lost Tapes: How Axl Rose Killed the 1995 Guns N' Roses Reunion
In 1995, a GNR comeback was near. Izzy Stradlin, Duff McKagan, and Matt Sorum recorded ten demos to recapture their early sound. Axl Rose rejected nine, liking only a punk cover. The project collapsed, the tapes were shelved, and the classic lineup's last hope was extinguished.
By the mid-1990s, the Guns N' Roses empire, once the most dangerous force in rock and roll, was beginning to crumble. The colossal Use Your Illusion tours had concluded, leaving the band exhausted and fractured. Their 1993 punk covers album, "The Spaghetti Incident?", felt more like a placeholder than a new direction. With creative tensions at an all-time high, especially between Axl Rose and Slash, the future was uncertain. But for a brief moment in 1995, a reunion of the band's core creative minds almost pulled them back from the brink.
A Glimmer of Hope: The Return of Izzy
The key to this potential comeback was Izzy Stradlin, the band's original rhythm guitarist and co-songwriter, who had quit in 1991, citing the overwhelming scale and drama of the band. In 1995, he quietly reconnected with bassist Duff McKagan and drummer Matt Sorum. The trio decided to get back to basics and write music together, hoping to recapture the lean, raw energy that defined Appetite for Destruction. They set up shop in Duff’s home studio and began working on new material, free from the pressure and excesses that had plagued the band.
Ten Demos and a New Direction
The sessions were incredibly productive. The trio laid down ten complete demo tracks. According to those who have spoken about the sessions, the music was a deliberate departure from the orchestral complexity of the Use Your Illusion albums. It was straightforward, blues-infused hard rock—the kind of music that had made them famous. This was the sound many fans and critics craved, a return to the street-level grit of early GNR. The stage was set for a triumphant return. All they needed was the approval of the band's frontman.
Axl's Decisive Veto
When the demos were ready, Axl Rose flew in to hear what the band had created. The fate of the project rested on his reaction. Unfortunately, his vision for the future of Guns N' Roses was starkly different. Of the ten songs presented to him, Axl allegedly rejected nine. The only track he expressed interest in was a cover of the punk band Fear's song, "I Don't Care About You," which had already been released on "The Spaghetti Incident?". The new, original material was dismissed. For Izzy, Duff, and Matt, this was a devastating blow. Drummer Matt Sorum later reflected on the moment:
We went in and recorded a bunch of songs. And it wasn’t received well by the singer. I remember being really disappointed... He just wasn’t into it. It was the beginning of the end for that particular version of the band.
The Aftermath and the Lost Tapes
Axl's rejection effectively killed the project. Disheartened, Izzy Stradlin once again walked away. His attempt to steer the ship back to its roots had failed. This event widened the existing cracks within the band, and by 1996, Slash had officially quit, followed by Duff in 1997. The classic-era lineup was definitively over. The ten demos were shelved and have never been officially released, becoming a holy grail for die-hard fans—a lost album that represents the last, best chance the original band had to save itself. Some of the musical ideas may have later surfaced on Izzy’s solo album 117° or projects like Neurotic Outsiders, but the world never got to hear what a 1995 Guns N' Roses record could have sounded like. It remains one of rock's greatest "what ifs," a ghost of an album that haunts the band's legacy.