in
Entertainment & Media
—
The Shout That Started It All: How One Line Birthed the Rocky Horror Cult
The chaotic audience participation at The Rocky Horror Picture Show began in 1976. It all started when a quiet teacher, Louis Farese Jr., yelled "Buy an umbrella you cheap bitch!" at the screen during a midnight show, transforming the film into a legendary interactive experience forever.
For nearly half a century, attending a midnight showing of The Rocky Horror Picture Show has been a rite of passage. It’s an interactive, chaotic, and liberating experience unlike any other in cinema. You don’t just watch the film; you become part of it, armed with toast, water pistols, and a script of callbacks shouted in unison. But this legendary tradition didn't emerge fully formed. It started with a single moment of audience frustration in a small New York City theater, sparked by one unforgettable line.
From Box Office Flop to Midnight Mecca
When The Rocky Horror Picture Show was released in 1975, it was a critical and commercial disaster. It was quickly pulled from most theaters, destined for obscurity. However, a young executive at 20th Century Fox named Tim Deegan saw potential in its weirdness and convinced the studio to try a midnight run at the Waverly Theater in Greenwich Village, starting on April 1, 1976. The Waverly became a haven for a small but dedicated group of regulars who returned week after week. They fell in love with the film's campy charm and its celebration of being an outsider. For months, they watched quietly, internalizing every song, line, and camera angle.
The Shout Heard 'Round the World
The quiet devotion broke about five months into the Waverly's run. During a showing, the film reached the scene where Brad and Janet's car breaks down in a storm. As Janet (Susan Sarandon) shields her head from the downpour with a newspaper, a quiet, unassuming schoolteacher from Staten Island named Louis Farese Jr. had finally had enough. He broke the silence of the theater, shouting a line that would echo through cinematic history:
Buy an umbrella, you cheap bitch!
The audience erupted in laughter. It was a perfect, spontaneous moment of commentary that broke the sacred fourth wall between the audience and the screen. It wasn't just a heckle; it was an invitation. Farese later admitted he was a shy person, but something about the film made him feel comfortable enough to yell. That single shout gave everyone else permission to join in.
A Tradition is Born
Farese's line opened the floodgates. The following week, other regulars came armed with their own callbacks. The audience began talking back to the characters, answering their rhetorical questions, and pointing out continuity errors. The participation quickly evolved beyond just words. When a character proposes a toast, someone threw a piece of actual toast at the screen. When it rained on Brad and Janet, people brought water guns. The screening became a living, breathing performance where the audience’s creativity was as much a part of the show as the film itself. Fan clubs, like the one led by Sal Piro, began to form, helping to document, refine, and spread the tradition to theaters across the country. What started as a joke at the Waverly became the codified ritual that defines Rocky Horror to this day—a testament to how one person's spontaneous outburst can create a lasting community.