in
Wars, Conflict & Heroes
—
'They Had No Choice': The Story of London's Powerful Animals in War Memorial
London's Animals in War Memorial honors the millions of animals who served and died in human conflicts. Its most powerful inscription, 'They had no choice,' serves as a solemn reminder of their silent, involuntary sacrifice and the true, far-reaching cost of war.
On the edge of London's Hyde Park, at Brook Gate on Park Lane, stands a monument of profound emotional weight. It isn't for a king, a general, or a politician. Instead, the Animals in War Memorial is a powerful and poignant tribute to the countless animals that served, suffered, and died alongside soldiers in human conflicts. And carved into its stone is an inscription that stops visitors in their tracks:
They had no choice.
This simple, four-word sentence captures the heartbreaking essence of their story. While humans enlist, volunteer, or are conscripted, animals were simply taken. They were tools of war, companions in chaos, and silent victims caught in the crossfire of conflicts they could never comprehend.
A Debt That Can Never Be Repaid
The scale of animal involvement in 20th-century warfare is staggering. The First World War alone saw over eight million horses, donkeys, and mules perish. They were the engines of the army, hauling artillery, carrying supplies, and charging into battle. But the list extends far beyond equines. Dogs served as messengers, guards, and medics, locating wounded soldiers on the battlefield. Over 100,000 carrier pigeons delivered vital messages, flying through shellfire to save lives. Canaries detected poison gas in the trenches, camels traversed deserts, and elephants moved heavy equipment in the jungles of the Far East. These creatures served on every front, their contributions immeasurable and their sacrifice immense.
A Sculpture of Sacrifice
Unveiled by HRH The Princess Royal in November 2004, the memorial, designed by sculptor David Backhouse, is a masterpiece of symbolic storytelling. It consists of a long, curved stone wall representing the arena of war. Two heavily-laden bronze mules are depicted struggling up towards a gap in this wall, their strain palpable. Through the gap, a bronze horse and a dog emerge on the other side, gazing forward into an uncertain future. Carved into the back of the wall in low relief are images of the other animals who served, a silent menagerie of the forgotten. The monument doesn't glorify war; it portrays the grim, relentless journey and the suffering of its most innocent participants.
Heroes Without a Voice
While the memorial honors them collectively, countless individual stories of animal bravery exist. There was Wojtek, a Syrian brown bear adopted by Polish soldiers, who learned to carry heavy ammunition crates to resupply artillery during the Battle of Monte Cassino. There was Simon, the ship's cat aboard HMS Amethyst, who, despite being wounded by shrapnel, continued to hunt rats, protecting the crew's dwindling food supplies and boosting morale during the 101-day Yangtze Incident. Many of these animal heroes were posthumously awarded the PDSA Dickin Medal, often called the “animals’ Victoria Cross,” for conspicuous gallantry and devotion to duty.
A Lasting Reminder
The Animals in War Memorial serves as more than just a historical marker. It is a profound statement about the far-reaching consequences of human conflict. The phrase 'They had no choice' resonates so deeply because it speaks to a universal truth about innocence and exploitation. It forces us to confront the reality that war consumes everything in its path, sparing not even the creatures who share our world. It is a place of quiet reflection, reminding us that in remembering the fallen, we must remember all of them.