Vanished into Thin Air: The Chilling, Unsolved Mystery of the Springfield Three

In 1992, Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall vanished from a Springfield, MO home. Their cars, purses, and keys were left behind. The only sign of a disturbance was a broken porch light, leaving a mystery that endures to this day.

It was the night of June 6, 1992. For high school seniors Suzie Streeter and Stacy McCall, it was a night of celebration. They had just graduated from Kickapoo High School in Springfield, Missouri, and were bouncing between graduation parties with friends, looking forward to the future. By the early hours of June 7, they headed back to Suzie’s house at 1717 East Delmar Street, where her mother, Sherrill Levitt, was waiting. They were the last people to see them alive. The next day, all three women were gone, having seemingly vanished into thin air, leaving behind a scene so normal it was terrifying.

An Eerie Silence on Delmar Street

When friends and family couldn't reach the women the next day, they grew concerned. Stacy’s mother, Janis McCall, visited the house and found the front door unlocked. Inside, the scene was unsettlingly mundane. Sherrill’s car, Suzie’s car, and Stacy’s car were all parked outside. The women's purses, containing their money, keys, and identification, were lined up on the floor. The television was still on. Sherrill’s bed looked as if she had been reading and had just gotten up. The only thing out of place in the entire home was a single, shattered glass globe on the front porch light. There were no signs of a struggle, no ransom note, and no clues as to where the three women could have gone.

A Botched Investigation and Decades of Dead Ends

In the crucial early hours, the scene was unintentionally contaminated. Worried friends and family, not realizing they were in a potential crime scene, cleaned up the broken glass from the porch light and answered a ringing phone, erasing a potentially disturbing message on the answering machine. The police investigation that followed was massive, generating over 5,000 tips, but every lead turned into a dead end. Despite being declared legally dead in 1997, the case remains an active missing persons investigation, a wound that has never closed for the community or the families involved.

Theories and Whispers

Over the decades, several persons of interest have emerged, but none have ever been charged in connection with the disappearances. The most prominent suspect is Robert Craig Cox, a convicted kidnapper and robber who was living in Springfield at the time. Cox has made cryptic statements to journalists, suggesting he knows what happened to the women.

Cox told journalists that he knew the women had been murdered and buried and that he would not reveal their location. He stated that he would disclose what happened to the women after his mother dies.

Other theories have surfaced, including a strange eyewitness account of Suzie driving a pale green van on the morning of her disappearance—a van that has never been identified. Another lead pointed to three men involved in a grave-robbing scheme, but searches of the land around their property yielded no evidence. Each theory is a tantalizing breadcrumb that leads nowhere concrete, leaving investigators and the public to speculate.

An Enduring Ozark Mystery

Today, the case of the Springfield Three remains one of America's most baffling unsolved mysteries. It haunts the public consciousness because of its chilling simplicity. Three women were home one minute and gone the next, leaving everything behind. There was no clear motive, no evidence, and no closure. For the families, the pain is unending, a constant state of not knowing. For the rest of us, it’s a terrifying reminder of how quickly a normal life can be upended, and how some questions may never be answered.

Sources