in
Art, Culture & Design
—
That's Not Crying: The Truth About the Man on the Cover of 'A Little Life'
The iconic cover of Hanya Yanagihara's 'A Little Life' is widely believed to depict a man crying in agony. In reality, it's Peter Hujar's 1969 photograph 'Orgasmic Man,' a raw portrayal of sexual ecstasy, chosen for its profound ambiguity between pleasure and pain.
If you've ever walked through a bookstore, the cover of Hanya Yanagihara's A Little Life has likely stopped you in your tracks. The black-and-white image of a man's face, contorted in what appears to be unbearable anguish, has become an icon of literary suffering. It's an image that perfectly prepares the reader for the harrowing, trauma-filled journey of its protagonist, Jude St. Francis. There is, however, one critical detail that most people miss: the man isn't crying. He isn't in pain. He's in the throes of an orgasm.
The Reveal: From Agony to Ecstasy
The striking photograph is titled Orgasmic Man (1), taken in 1969 by the celebrated American photographer Peter Hujar. This revelation reframes the entire visual narrative of the novel before you even open to the first page. What is widely interpreted as a portrait of pure suffering is, in fact, a depiction of intense pleasure. This disconnect between perception and reality is at the heart of why the image is such a profoundly perfect choice for this divisive and deeply affecting novel.
Who Was Peter Hujar?
To understand the photograph, one must understand the artist. Peter Hujar (1934-1987) was a key figure in the downtown New York City art scene of the 1970s and 80s. He was known for his stark, intimate, and psychologically piercing black-and-white portraits. His subjects, often his friends and fellow artists like Susan Sontag and David Wojnarowicz, were captured with a raw vulnerability. Hujar's work strips away artifice, focusing on the complex interior lives of his subjects. Orgasmic Man is a prime example of his ability to capture a private, unguarded moment and elevate it to high art.
The Thin Line Between Pleasure and Pain
The power of Hujar's photograph lies in its ambiguity. The human face, when pushed to the extremes of sensation, can look remarkably similar in both ecstasy and agony. The tense muscles, the closed eyes, the open mouth—it's a moment of complete physical and emotional surrender. It is this very ambiguity that captivated author Hanya Yanagihara. As noted in The Guardian, the image struck her because it seemed to capture a state beyond a simple binary emotion.
For her, the photograph, which she first saw on the cover of a German photography magazine, seemed to transcend pain. The man in it, she has said, “is in a state of ecstasy, but he’s in a state of ecstasy that is so pure and so total that it looks like he’s in agony.”
This quote perfectly encapsulates the cover's thematic resonance. A Little Life is a novel about a character, Jude, whose entire existence is defined by the oscillation between extreme pain from his past and the profound, almost transcendent love he finds in his friendships. The cover is not just a picture of his pain; it is a picture of his entire, complex emotional spectrum, where joy and suffering are inextricably linked.
A New Lens on a Modern Classic
Knowing the truth behind the cover of A Little Life doesn't diminish the novel's exploration of suffering. Instead, it enriches it. It forces us to see Jude not as a figure of pure victimhood, but as a person grappling with the full, complicated scope of human experience. The cover challenges the reader to look closer, to question their initial assumptions, and to understand that even in the darkest narratives, there are complex undercurrents of life, desire, and moments of ecstasy, however fleeting they may be. It is a testament to the power of art that a single image can contain such a universe of meaning, perfectly mirroring the little life held within the book's pages.