The Audacious Plan to Revive George Washington with Lamb's Blood

A Desperate Silence at Mount Vernon

On the frigid night of December 14, 1799, a profound stillness fell over Mount Vernon. George Washington was dead. His final illness had been swift and brutal—a throat infection that modern doctors believe was acute epiglottitis. The era's finest medical minds, armed with the era's most fearsome tools, had subjected him to a torrent of treatments. He was bled of several pints of blood, his throat blistered with Spanish fly, and made to gargle mixtures of molasses, vinegar, and butter. Nothing worked. The hero of the Revolution, the nation's first president, had succumbed not on the battlefield, but in his bed, surrounded by physicians who could only watch him suffocate.

An Architect of Radical Ideas

Into this scene of grief rode Dr. William Thornton, a man whose ambition was matched only by his eclectic genius. Thornton was not just a physician; he was a Quaker, an abolitionist, an inventor, and, most famously, the original architect of the U.S. Capitol Building. He was a friend of the Washingtons and arrived from Alexandria as fast as his horse could carry him, but he was too late. Yet, where others saw a tragic end, Thornton saw a medical challenge. He refused to accept that Washington was gone for good. He approached the grieving Martha Washington with a proposal that was audacious even for an age of bold experimentation—he wanted to bring the president back from the dead.

The Resurrection Recipe

Thornton's plan was a strange cocktail of fledgling science and sheer, desperate hope. He argued that the president's body, having been laid in a cool room, was not truly dead but in a state of suspended animation, preserved by the cold. His method for revival was alarmingly specific. First, they would bring the body to a fire, slowly thawing it while rubbing the skin with blankets to restore warmth and circulation. The next step was more invasive. Thornton proposed performing a tracheotomy—an incision in Washington's windpipe—to insert a bellows and manually inflate his lungs with air, forcing the body to breathe again. The final, most startling step, was to introduce life back into Washington's veins. He would perform a blood transfusion, not with human blood, but with the fresh, warm blood of a lamb.

A Moment of Decision

The proposal hung in the air, a shocking intrusion on the family's sorrow. The other physicians present, Drs. James Craik and Elisha Cullen Dick, had already endured a grueling night. Dr. Dick, the youngest of the attending doctors, had even argued against the final, aggressive bloodletting, showing a caution that was ahead of its time. To them, Thornton’s plan likely sounded less like medicine and more like desecration. The idea of transfusing animal blood was not entirely new—crude experiments had been performed in Europe for decades—but it was wildly dangerous and almost universally fatal due to immune rejection, a concept not yet understood. The decision, however, ultimately rested with a widow in the depths of grief. Martha Washington, perhaps guided by a desire to let her husband rest in peace after his painful ordeal, politely declined the doctor's bizarre experiment.

A Legacy Left Undisturbed

Washington's body was not subjected to Thornton's strange ritual. He was laid to rest three days later, as per his own instructions. The story of the resurrection plan, however, endures as more than a macabre footnote. It's a stark snapshot of a medical world on the cusp of discovery, where the line between life and death was still a blurry, negotiable frontier. Thornton's desperate gamble reveals a very human impulse: the refusal to let go of our heroes and the belief that ingenuity, however misguided, can conquer even death itself. In the end, Washington was left to history, and the lamb was spared, leaving behind one of the most curious 'what if' scenarios in American history.

Sources

• The Surprising George Washington | National Archives
• The Bizarre Plan to Bring George Washington Back to Life | HISTORY
• Dr. Thornton's Radical Idea of Bringing George Washington Back to ...
• Inside The Morbid Attempt To Resurrect George Washington With ...
• The man who wanted to resurrect George Washington
• A day after George Washington's death, a doctor proposed a bizarre ...
• This Doctor Actually Tried To Resurrect George Washington From ...